Sunday, September 7, 2008

The Promise of $2,500 Savings: Part I

The biggest, most substantial -- whatever you want to call it -- portion of the Obama health plan is the $2,500 promise.

It has been part of the Obama plan from the beginning. The long version of the plan put out by Senator Obama's plan put it in a box at the beginning of the document: "Under the Obama plan, the typical family will save up to $2,500 every year..." Now there was a bit of shading in the words "up to". That was the formulation in Senator Obama's speech when he announced his plan in his May 27, 2007 speech at the University of Iowa: "I want to lay out the details of that plan - a plan that not only guarantees coverage for every American, but also brings down the cost of health care and reduces every family's premiums by as much as $2,500." [Emphasis added.]

The $2,500 promise had its origin at a time when Sen. Hillary Clinton was the frontrunner for the Democratic nomination. Her rhetoric emphasized coverage; her plan had the title, "American Health Choices Plan: Quality, Affordable Health Care for Every American." For "Americans who are satisfied with the coverage they have today," the Clinton plan said, they "can keep it, while benefiting from lower premiums and higher quality."

Senator Obama gave more emphasis to the growing cost of health care. His University of Iowa speech emphasized the relationship of coverage and cost. After the sentence quoted above, he continued, "This second part is important because, in the end, coverage without cost containment will only shift our burdens, not relieve them."

One can envision the scene as the University of Iowa speech was drafted:
"This will help us distinguish Sen. Obama from Sen. Clinton."
"But it needs to be more concrete."
"Yeah, let's put a number in here."
And somehow the debate settled on $2,500. Talk about sticking in a shovel and digging a hole. Is this possible? And even if possible, is it plausible? Addressing this question will take several posts.

The $2,500 promise could have been left behind in the haze of the primary season. But it seems to be very much alive. Senator Obama reaffirmed this approach in his acceptance speech at the Democratic National Convention: "[I]f you have health care, my plan will lower your premiums..." Senator Biden, in his acceptance speech, didn't say it was premiums that would be lowered, but he did say it would be $2,500: "Barack Obama will bring down health care costs by $2,500 for the typical family, and, at long last, deliver affordable, accessible health care for all Americans."

Next: What could be meant by saving "up to $2,500"?

Friday, September 5, 2008

In 100 words or fewer, what is the Obama health plan?

100 words or fewer, describe the Obama plan:

The Obama/Biden health plan’s most substantial components are (1) a commitment to saving “the typical family” up to $2,500 per year in health insurance premiums by making the health care system more efficient, (2) subsidies to ensure that health insurance is affordable, (3) a requirement for employers to buy coverage for their workers or pay a payroll tax (4) a new national health plan that will set a floor for what health insurance can be (5 ) a new mechanism to buy insurance called a “national health insurance exchange” and (6) a mandate that parents obtain health insurance for their children.


There, that’s it in 100 words. Got a different 100 words? Post them in the comments.

My ordering is based on (1) dollars moved around, (2) people moved around and (3) degree of policy change. If I could have a few more words, I would next add the proposal for the government to provide catastrophic health insurance to those in employer health plans. Depending on what’s counted as “catastrophic,” this has the potential to wind up higher in the “most substantial” list. Then comes “expansion of Medicaid and SCHIP.” Expand Medicaid and SCHIP enough and it could move up. Policy novelty? None. It both cases, the lack of detail in the Obama plan makes it anyone’s guess what is truly most substantial.

Note that the prevention and public health agenda isn’t here. If you read the Obama source documents (see yesterday’s post) and relied only on word counts as the measure of importance, prevention/public health would make it into the “100 words or less” description. However, when weighting by dollars at stake, prevention and public health don’t make it. Yes, “many Americans go without high-value preventive services, such as cancer screening and immunizations,” as it says in Barack Obama’s Plan for a Healthy America but we don’t learn there what an Obama Administration would do about it. When the rhetoric is descriptive rather than prescriptive, in contrast to the clear promise of $2,500 in premium savings or employer mandates, its hard to put prevention and public health higher in the rankings.

Thursday, September 4, 2008

How does Senator Obama describe his health plan?

Sen. Obama's health plan is set out in two documents; closely related are a FAQ document and the speech Sen. Obama gave when he released his plan.

The shorter, more bullet-point version is "Plan for a Healthy America."
I downloaded my copy in the Spring, and while the document has remained about the same, there's been at least one change, a topic for a later post.

There is also "Barack Obama's Plan for a Healthy America," a document whose file name, "HealthPlanFull," explains what it is.

If you want the FAQs, they are also available.

Senator Obama announced his plan in a speech entitled "Cutting Costs and Covering America: A 21st Century Health Care System," delivered on May 29, 2007, at the University of Iowa.

That's about it for authoritative documents that lay out the plan. The documents from the campaign do not provide the detail to answer questions like "How much will the plan cost?" and "How many people will get assistance and how much will they get?" The best clues for answering this sort of question come from a document that I'd have to call semi-authoritative. It isn't from the campaign. Rather, it comes from three advisers to the campaign (and opens "The Obama campaign asked us...") It's a memo to "Interested Parties" and the only place to find what I would describe as policy analysis rather than policy description that traces back to the Obama campaign.